The decline of watchdog journalism in Manipur and across India: A call for introspection

Must Read

- Advertisement -spot_img

THE STATE of journalism in India, including in Manipur, requires thorough introspection and a willingness to accept public criticism. As the fourth pillar of a democracy, the media must act as a watchdog rather than merely relaying surface-level information that already floods social media. Unfortunately, current trends show a stark departure from this ideal, with many journalists acting as spin doctors for political parties. A telling example is the recent viral video of a television anchor claiming that air pollution creates a protective layer that blocks direct sunlight and stops it from burning the skin, an absurd attempt to shield the ruling party from public criticism over worsening air quality. Equally troubling is the cozy relationship between today’s journalists and politicians. Rather than pressing leaders for accountability, many journalists appear more eager to build closer ties and casual relationships with ministers.

Also Read: The Prison of Geography Kangleipak, Manipur and the Unfinished Compact

A critical look at daily television broadcasts and newspapers reveals a glaring lack of investigative reporting. Instead, lead stories frequently read like public relations campaigns praising government claims and achievements. As British publisher Lord Northcliffe famously noted, “News is what somebody somewhere wants to suppress; all the rest is advertising”.

The broken legacy of journalism in Manipur: Manipur boasts a rich journalistic heritage dating back to the 1920s, beginning with the handwritten journal “Meitei Chanu” by social reformer Hijam Irabot. This pioneering foundation eventually evolved into vernacular daily newspapers that championed anti-colonial resistance, political awareness, and cultural preservation. Later, stalwart journalist – NK Sanajaoba, rightly remembered as the “father of investigative journalism in Manipur”, set a gold standard for authentic reporting. He scrutinized government machinery and exposed deep-seated scandals within State departments. In the modern era, journalists such as Yambem Laba and Pradip Phanjoubam carried this torch forward through critical reporting and incisive editorials on administrative lapses. Today, however, that legacy has largely fractured. Despite widespread corruption eroding society, hard-hitting reports on government failures in Manipur have become exceedingly rare.

Also Read: The Tide of Accountability Is Rising in Manipur

The impact of Corporate Ownership and State revenue: The increasing takeover of media houses by large corporations has severely compromised journalistic objectivity across the country. Many once-respected newspapers and television channels have been reduced to mouthpieces for the ruling class. Corporations frequently fund political parties during elections in exchange for favorable policies later. When corporate-backed governments enact policies that harm ordinary citizens to benefit big business, it is the media’s duty to challenge them. However, corporate-owned media houses have little incentive to critique the very systems that enrich their owners. In addition, heavy financial reliance on government advertisements makes newsrooms reluctant to publish anything that might displease the ruling establishment.

Shrinking spaces for Watchdog Journalists: As governments grow increasingly hostile toward critical reporting, the backlash against independent journalists intensifies. Fearing political and financial reprisal, corporate media managers routinely pressure reporters to soften their tone or ignore administrative failures altogether.This environment has led to the targeting, ousting, or forced resignation of numerous prominent journalists across India. While many young, aspiring reporters still wish to expose corruption and social evils, they are stifled by systemic pressures and lack platforms to publish their work.

The cascading threat to democracy: If this trend of ignoring government failures continues, the future of our democracy is in peril. When the press fails to hold power to account, citizens are kept in the dark about administrative defects and policy failures. Deprived of accurate information, the public cannot make informed choices at the ballot box, paving the way for unchecked authoritarianism.

Accepting criticism and finding hope: It is high time for media houses and journalists to acknowledge genuine public criticism regarding their declining standards. Journalists must ask themselves why systemic corruption and scandals go unreported in mainstream news. Despite the grim landscape, glimmers of hope remain. Courageous investigative work, such as journalist Ritika Chopra’s recent reporting on controversies surrounding the Election Commission of India, alongside reports of Supreme Court-mandated disclosures by other news outlets, proves that impactful journalism is still possible.

The rise of independent digital platforms: As space within traditional newsrooms shrinks, independent YouTube channels, digital news portals, and podcasts have emerged as vital alternatives. These platforms offer outspoken and uncompromising journalists the freedom to report without corporate or State interference. Moving forward, digital media will likely continue to attract principled journalists determined to keep the true spirit of the fourth estate alive.

(The views expressed are personal. The author can be reached at nandowaikhom601@gmail.com)

- Advertisement -

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest News

Senapati District Frontal Organisations Hold Condolence Service in Memory of Six Naga Civilians Killed

SENAPATI: Senapati district frontal organizations including the Naga People’s Organization (NPO), Senapati District Women’s Association (SDWA) and Senapati District...
- Advertisement -

More Articles Like This

- Advertisement -